Following a significant regulatory appeal, a national review panel has overturned a earlier ruling that blocked viewers in Australia from seeing recorded content of the shooting incident involving conservative commentator Charlie Kirk. This challenge was initiated by Elon Musk's social media platform, arguing against an directive issued at the request of the national eSafety commissioner.
Details of the Original Ban
Following the death of Charlie Kirk at a US campus in last year, the regulator petitioned the classification board to officially classify the available footage. The board initially ruled the content was "unable to be classified", a rating that allowed the regulator to order social media companies to geo-block the posts for users in Australia.
Elon Musk's company challenged the decision for two separate videos depicting the Kirk incident. Additionally, it contested a comparable ban on a separate video—depicting the assault of Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte—which had likewise been deemed "refused classification".
Arguments Presented and Board's Decision
Arguing its case, X asserted that the Kirk video contained only a short moment of violence with no visible weapon. The company noted the recording was low-quality and the focus shifted rapidly from the victim to the bystanders.
The social media giant maintained the footage was not excessively detailed, exploitative, or objectionable, stating it served as a neutral objective record of "a notorious public event of public importance that prompted extensive public discourse". X even compared the footage and the historic film of President John F. Kennedy's assassination.
Most members of the review board ultimately agreed that, "notwithstanding the heinous nature of the event," the content did not reach a level that was gratuitous, exploitative or offensive enough to justify a complete ban. However, they noted that a longer or clearer version with different editing could have resulted in a different ruling. As a result, the panel changed the rating of the content to R18+.
The Minority Opinion
A minority on the board disagreed, contending the video was "a shareable video for the probable aim of amusement and/or benefit (such as engagement metrics)". This view stated the parallel with the Zapruder JFK film was flawed, as that footage was made public long after the assassination, "once emotions around the matter had subsided".
Reactions to the Decision
Posting on its global government affairs account, the platform expressed approval of the decision.
"X fought this decision to defend freedom of expression and the critical nature of access to information about matters of public significance. We remain committed to safeguarding these principles."
A spokesperson for the eSafety commissioner acknowledged the ruling, but noted that the revised classification now means platforms "have obligations to ensure R18+ material being displayed to Australians who are minors".
Recent Developments on Sensitive Footage
Separately, the eSafety commissioner did not issue take-down orders to platforms this week regarding graphic footage from the Sydney beach incident circulating on social media. The regulator stated that while the images were upsetting, they did not reach the required standard for a "total ban" rating.
As an alternative, platforms have been advised to use sensitive content labels and screens, such as obscuring the image, on this material in accordance with their existing community guidelines.